Total Pageviews

Friday, February 14, 2014

THE WEDGEFIELD EXAMINER WILL PROVIDE A REPORT AND TRANSCRIPTION OF THE OPEN MEETING ON fEBRUARY 12TH, REGARDING HIRING A ATTORNEY OF RECORD. THE ARTICLE WILL BE PUBLISHED BY END OF DAY ON FEBRUARY 16TH.

BEFORE PRESENTING THE INFORMATION, THE WEDGEFIELD EXAMINER ASKS THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS:

DID THE BOARD ACTING AS A PRUDENT PERSON WOULD, EVER CONSIDER THE WORD INTERIM?

WHY WOULD YOU HIRE AN ATTORNEY OF RECORD WHO HAS TOLD YOU IN THE PAST, THAT THEY DON'T HAVE ANY ASSOCIATION EXPERIENCE?

Finally, it is too bad that I'm not a betting person.  We could have had our Valentine's Day dinner on my winnings.  A BIG THANKS TO R. Vaughan for taping the meeting.  Be sure and visit The Wedgefield Times for tapes of the WPA monthly meetings and his comments.  When you and I can't, or are not inclined to be at the meetings, he is!

A THANK YOU TO THE WPA BOARD, A NOTICE, AND QUESTIONS

A BIG THANK YOU TO THE BOARD
Wednesday's storm brought down literally tons of limbs and branches.  Your board acted quickly to arrange for services to clean up the debris and notified residents regarding the service.  THANKS!!!!!!

A NOTICE
The Wedgefield Examiner had hoped to attend the open board meeting on Wednesday evening, regarding legal.  With branches and limbs falling throughout the day, I felt I should stay in.  We'll have to wait for the legal report at next Tuesday's regular monthly meeting to see if the board met and what decisions they made.

QUESTIONS
The membership will have to wait for a grounds report at the February board meeting.  Did the board honor the terms of the grounds contractor contract, when they hired a contractor to clean up the debris from the storm.  In the past, that hasn't always been the case.  The Wedgefield Examiner doesn't have any information, and is not making an accusation, just posing a question.

Who is our new attorney of record?

Attend the meeting next Tuesday to find out.


Tuesday, February 11, 2014

President Jacky Walton, has called an OPEN Board Meeting for Feb. 12 at 7:00PM. The agenda is to discuss THE ATTORNEY OF RECORD. WILL PERTINENT QUESTIONS BE ASKED BY THE BOARD AND ANSWERED BEFORE A VOTE IS TAKEN ON HOW TO MOVE FORWARD, OR WILL THIS JUST BE ANOTHER SILENT RAISING OF THEIR HANDS?

To date, The Wedgefield Examiner has been unable to locate the accusations brought against our current Attorney of Record - Moody, that caused the Supreme Court of South Carolina to place him on temporary suspension and appoint a Special Receiver.  While these recent actions may have put our association in a bad place, we were there already.

During the January WPA board meeting, when it was announced that Moody had split from the law firm of Maring and Moody, Garrison said he didn't know where Moody was, and when asked the reason for the split, said he didn't care.  Yet, someone at the board table stated that they had talked to him, and he would cover upcoming court dates.  Did your board care so little that while one of them had him on the phone that they didn't question why the split, or even ask where his new office was?  That's pretty elementary.  No one on that board, except for McBride, asked any pertinent questions in behalf of the association.  They just sat there, including our president.  According to the Supreme Court Order, Moody won't be representing us any where soon.

As Special Receiver , Maring sent a letter to Moody's clients, advising them to pick up their files.  Any files left in his possession at the termination of his appointment will be turned over to the Commission on Lawyer Conduct in Columbia.  Call it my suspicious mind, but I forecast that this board will turn our records over to Maring and ask him to pick up our case load.  That would be the easy way out and may not be in our best interests.  Why?

Up until recently these two attorneys were a membership of two, in the firm.  The firm has accepted payment for  services that our now Legal Chair, said as a board member, we wouldn't pay because two other board members had sought the firm's services, without board approval.  The firm met with a Concerned Citizen private resident, charged, and were paid.  There were other questionable charges that were paid.  VERY few legal opinions have been put in writing so that each board member may read and weigh the matter discussed, before a vote.  It could be called an unhealthy relationship.  Now, there isn't a paper trail where board members, or residents, can go back and review opinions, now that the association is placed in this situation.  Legal Chair, Garrison has stated at times that he "wasn't inclined to pay for written opinions" (go back to tapes of the meetings). Moody's apparent acceptance of this could be indication of the then firm's failure to recognize the needs of the entire board.

Our own Wedgefield situation regarding legal is questionable.  A few years back, Jacky Walton was removed as president by the board because he wouldn't fire his appointed legal chair( A very responsible legal chair.).  At that time, then board member, Huggins, said, "it was all about legal."  Walton has been elected by this board twice, as president.  Each time, he has named Garrison as legal chair.  During each of these appointments, Garrison has been working with the attorney of record to collect on assessments, he previously put in writing, to put in escrow and not pay.  Is Walton retaining his presidency because once again, it is all about legal?  In the mean time, most of these board members take the easy way out to retain their own dukedom, and fail to serve in our best interests.  I'm not a betting person, if I was I'd wager that on Thursday morning, Maring will be our attorney of record.

Will you attend the meeting?

Saturday, February 8, 2014

WHEN BOARD MEMBER MC BRIDE QUESTIONED THE LEGAL CHAIR DURING THE JANUARY WPA BOARD MEETING, HE WAS IGNORED. OUR LEGAL CHAIR WAS UNCONCERNED. OUR PRESIDENT SAT BY AND NEGLECTED TO SPEAK OUT IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF OUR ASSOCIATION. THE MAJORITY OF YOUR BOARD SAT BY. MC BRIDE WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO DID THE RIGHT THING. THE WEDGEFIELD EXAMINER SAID YOUR BOARD AND PRESIDENT'S BEHAVIOR WEREN'T IN OUR BEST INTERESTS

Please take a few minutes and read the article just prior to this one, regarding the January Legal Report.  The Wedgefield Examiner has removed the inside address of the document presented below to protect the identity of the resident (non board member), who provided it to the blog.  President Walton, isn't it time that you removed Garrison as Legal Chair?  Isn't it time that you and the rest of the board began to consider the questions of Mc Bride?  Isn't it time that you acted in our behalf, at least questioned what any prudent person would? Perhaps this board will consider the value of WRITTEN opinions now.  Otherwise, we are left with what one board member called "hear say".  Now our association is left with nothing to refer to in writing to verify, or review.  Here is the letter regarding our board attorney of record.

 
THE FOLLOWING IS THE SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH CAROLINA ORDER
 
 


Thursday, February 6, 2014

THE JANUARY 21 WPA LEGAL REPORT. WHERE EXACTLY IS OUR BOARD ATTORNEY OF RECORD? SHOULD THE BOARD BE LOOKING FOR A NEW LAWYER? SOMETHING NOT SO SURPRISING

NOTE: This is the first article pertaining to the January WPA Board Meeting.  As background, 7 board members are in attendance, as McMillin and Cline are absent.  9 members are in attendance at the meeting.  As I was listening to the tape, provided at The Wedgefield Times, the Legal Report brought questions and concerns.

I have transcribed the report to the best of my ability.  Please listen to the tape yourself for verification.  Garrison, Legal Chair, provides the report.  At times he comes across almost in conversation tone.  Perhaps the board should go back to providing the individual speakers with a microphone, to provide quality in the recording.  Direct quotes will be underlined and in quotation.  We'll call our attorney, attorney "M".

We begin with Garrison stating that there will need to be decisions about our current legal representation.  "The law firm we have been engaged with may not exist.  I think (believe the following word is correct) dissolved on January 10th.  (Can't understand a few words)  ......."M" gone off on his own.  At this point, I don't know where his office is, or if he even has one. "  He then says something about not necessarily changing attorneys but, we might have to get a new contract with him.  Later he begins to speak about the legal collections in progress and says he has a spread sheet of some of these ongoing foreclosures and "stuff".  Still later, he says, "defendants in the canal assessment, that's still dragging on and gee, it has only been 3 years"

President Walton asks about a court date this month and whether our attorney will be representing us?  I believe, (could be wrong) the answer comes from DeMarchi, who says something about the fact that he's assured him that he's prepared to take care of those cases.

McBride, "I think....reason for this law firm to dissolve as it did.....I think this board needs to understand some of that before we just agree that yes, we'll proceed with the same attorney that we have. Was it some sort of missing funds that caused this problem?  What was it?  These things don't just happen for some good reason." 

President Walton jumps in and says that they don't know the reason and are just going to have to wait and find out what's going on.

McBride says they need to find out the reason.

Garrison, "I don't think it is the board's, or anyone else's business, what a private entity does if they elect to dissolve.......My understanding, from what little I was told was that "M" decided to go out on his own.  I've only heard one piece of it from one side of it.  When I called (He names the firm.) office and asked what was going on, the only answers I got was, I don't know.  Unless the guy lost his law license, or is under indictment, or something, and that was the cause of it, why they elected to do this, my feeling from what (Names attorney by first name.) told me was that it was his decision, but I don't know that for a fact.  I'm not going to pretend that I do.  Our job is to decide who you want to have as an attorney.  I don't .....not really concerned what their feelings are.....maybe their wives don't get along, didn't like each other, or whatever. I have no idea and frankly I don't care."

During the report Garrison also informs the group the by-law change passed at the 2013 meeting has been legally registered. 

COMMENTS:
This appears to be a real nonchalant attitude by our Legal Chair in both the discussion about a key element in the board's responsibility and his criteria - not indicted, hasn't lost his law license.  He states he doesn't know where the attorney is, why the firm, or partnership was dissolved and he personally isn't inclined to find our why.  Yet, he or someone else speaking at the board table, has spoken to the attorney and been reassured that he'll meet some upcoming court dates.  No one on the board questions, but for one.  They just move on.

Remember, this particular attorney came to us under unusual circumstance.  Moran was attorney of record and gave a WRITTEN legal opinion regarding the 2011 recall effort.  Then board members, Huggins and Wilson, went off on their own without the approval of the board, and sought the advice of attorney "M", who we're told didn't agree with Moran.  At the time, Garrison said the board would not pay for the opinion and Huggins said they wouldn't be charged.  In the end, not only were they charged, but there was also an  accumulation of approximately $5,000 in fees from this attorney, such a meetings with one of the chief female Concerned Citizens (not a board member).  Garrison sat on the board that paid those fees.  Additionally, from the beginning Garrison and attorney "M" have not put most (very few - count on one hand) legal opinions in writing, so that board members could review opinions for themselves, before they vote on issues.

The current contract is with a firm, a entity, which if it doesn't exist any more cancels the contract and diminishes credibility.  There should have been a vote by the board to determine whether attorney "M" should proceed at all and bill.  Surprised?  I'm not.  This board, in general does what they want, when they want, and just keeps going.  Should we continue with an attorney who has this history?????? 

You'll note Garrison all but laughs at the state of collection on the $5,000 canal collection progression.  Again, should he be Legal Chair when he and one of the Legal Committee members told our residents in writing, to put those monies in escrow?   Our president seems oblivious.  At the end of the report, he says, "Thank you Bob."

SOMETHING NOT SO SURPRISING?????  I could have bet on this!  Close friends will tell you that I said it would be the case.  Garrison announced that the 2013 by-law change that passed at the 2013 annual meeting, has been legally registered.  Some have said the by-law amendment was his. He did get a legal opinion in WRITING, from this attorney.  He is the same Legal Chair who ignored even verifying whether the 2011 by-law change was registered, for a year and a half.  President Walton, where are you?  Don't you see these things?  As important, because your board named Walton PRESIDENT, AND HE KEEPS NAMING THE SAME LEGAL CHAIR, where was your board when they voted to keep Walton as president?




Saturday, February 1, 2014

THE STATE OF THE UNION (WEDGEFIELD PLANTATION ASSOCIATION)

As I listened to President Obama's state of the union I wondered about ours. Except for the addition of one new face on the board, Keith Johnson, all of the board members sitting at the board table governed our association in 2013.  Past performance is a concrete prediction of future performance.  I spent a good deal of time reviewing meeting transcriptions, documents, etc., and prepared a month by month grid for 2013. It left me concerned for the future governance in 2014 by this board.

A WALK THROUGH THE HIGHLIGHTS OF GOVERNANCE IN 2013:

January 
* The Treasurer reports that the financial report contains erroneous information.  So as not to repeat this fact throughout the article,  please note that this goes on for months.  The words change each month to incorrect, etc. but the instability of information and  ever changing form of the reports continue through the entire year.
*Your board approves an "off the shelf" Reserve Study" to save money, despite the fact that we have never had one done, and will not pay for engineering support to the study.
*The board had the management company send assessments out due the end of January but will hamper their collection by taking steps to stop the application of late fees until March 1st.  A board member questions this move and the board ignores him.
*The president reports that the Reserve Study contract has been signed.  He is questioned as to whether the canals and spoil site were included in the study.  He reports that they were included in the proposal, but not the contract???????????????
February
*The Water Amenities Chair brings three bids to the board table to replace old dock one at the landing. A board member questions whether the old dock will be dissembled and removed so as not to "end up in our own back yard"?  The board is advised that the contractor will pull it up on the landing and it will be dissembled.  Watch how long this issue says on the table and the snake path the board takes to cover up the intentions and lies of this committee.
*The Drainage Chair would like to hire the association president's contracting business to do drainage work.  The Treasurer/Drainage Chair says the board will discuss this at a closed board meeting.  One board member asks about conflict of interest.  Watch for this issue to be discussed a few more times in 2013!
*Our president reports that the management company has quit.  The board's strangling of their ability to operate in a real business sense may have caused this.  The details are too long and twisted for this article.
*The board removes the spoil site from under the care of the Water Amenities Committee to Grounds????????????
*A resident discusses the board's failure to respond to residents during the comment section of the meeting.  This problem continues throughout the year.  Our president asks The Wedgefield Examiner what procedure she used to answer residents!
March
*Your board allows the GROUNDS' CHAIR to take a significant presentation period of time under New Business to give his non engineered, convoluted, costs derived off the top of his head, CANAL PROPOSAL  No one explains how he got on the agenda to discuss this topic. 
*The treasurer provides information on "the accounting function".  When asked by a board member whether a CPA  will be involved, the treasurer gets nasty, supported by others on the board.  Watch how this develops and how your board has never acknowledged the true expense. 
*The board Secretary reports that she expects to spend $500 on an event.  When asked by a board member whether she intends to make a motion and call  a vote for the expense, she says "no". No one else on the board discusses the fact that the rest have to.
*The Vice President/Legal Chair declares that the board is having difficulty securing bids for projects in Wedgefield.  He states the Drainage Chair/Treasurer/ Compliance Chair (who is about to do drainage work on his road and roads where he built homes??????) is having difficulty securing bids for his project and suggests the work be done by our president's contracting firm!!!!!!
*The President notifies residents of a closed board meeting, despite the fact that many of the individual board members campaigned against closed meetings!
*In the mean time, a board member's spouse leads the gossip train in the community on a serious private matter of a former board member, quoted as saying "that person would get their just due."  Watch for this spouse later as your board allows them a resident speaker spot to go after The Wedgefield Examiner during a WPA meeting.
*The old dock is dragged into "our back yard", the canals!
April
*A board member asks the Legal Chair if he has written legal opinions on an issue being discussed at the board table.  The answer is "no".  The questioning board member says, "all we have then is hear say".   The board secretary laughs and our President says, "carry on"!  Lack of written legal opinions continues throughout the year.
*The president loudly declares, "I'm the president", when he brings a surprise, non agenda item to the board table for a vote.  Our Treasurer seconds the motion!  When a board member questions the President, he yells that the board member is "out of order".
*The Treasurer brings a motion to the table to pay for training in Quick Books for our staff secretary.  The staff secretary will play a large role in the "accounting function".  This is just more of what is to come with our non professional "accounting function". 
*The old dock is still in the canals. Your board continues to cover for the Water Amenities' Chair.
*This meeting is so heated that the President doesn't even call for resident comments at the end of the meeting!
May
*The Grounds Chair discusses the potential grounds maintenance contract.  He wants to subsidize private lot mowing and add the spoil site maintenance to the contract (No expert or engineering support and the grounds' crew and equipment would have to be transported by volunteers).  Some on the board question it. Our Treasurer is adamant that we won't be subsidizing lot mowing.  Others on the board don't want to include the spoil site.  The new contract is delayed until August..  They extend the current contract until August and lots located between houses are left to grow knee high because there aren't any lot mowings left in the old contract.
*The Wedgefield Examiner schedules a review of the correspondence file over a six month period and documents that residents haven't been answered for six months and yet the Community Liaison continues to declare, "no report", as your President and entire board sit by.
*The old dock is still in the canals and your board continues to snake around it.
*"BUILDER DAMAGE":  Our Treasurer sends a email to the President - ONLY.  A builder has damaged the Treasurer's lawn.  The TREASURER advises the PRESIDENT, "I will have the lawn repaired and have the ASSOCIATION DEDUCT IT FROM THE OWNER DEPOSIT."   The Wedgefield Examiner does not believe that option is available to any of us.  It is available if damage is done to WPA property.  The "accounting function supervised by the Treasurer, no CPA, may have had to handle that transaction??????
*Our Treasurer introduces his "ACCOUNTANT" job description. There are no true education requirements - not even high school, for what he calls our ACCOUNTANT. A person is hired.  It doesn't appear a ad, or interview is conducted by anyone other than the Treasurer.  It is stated that the new hire calls herself a BOOKKEEPER.  No one tells us what the new hire is being paid and our ever changing financial reports don't allow us to review it.  One board member answers the question of cost by saying, "she works cheap".
*The Grounds' Chair argues with the board over the grounds' contract.  According to figures presented, we will be paying 40 - 50% of the mowing of PRIVATE LOTS.
*During the Drainage Report, our Drainage/ Treasurer/Compliance Chair is going to do more work in his backyard and where he built homes, at our expense.  A board member declares that residents have had to pay for their own drainage when they build.  In fact he had to when he built his home.  The Treasurer/Drainage/COMPLIANCE CHAIR pushes on saying "five or six drainage committees have known since 2007 the issues and he will fix it. He will be the first to fix it" (in his neighborhood and where he built homes).  When questioned again by a board member, the questioner is abused, and the action moves forward with the support of your board.
*A vote is taken to pay off the canal loan.
June
*The Wedgefield Examiner sends a letter, as a private resident, requesting the opportunity to review records.  The Treasurer, not the Community Liaison (Is he the Community Liaison at this point and your President hasn't announced it?) sends a response telling her she hasn't met the requirements of STATE LAW.  I respond asking if all residents are held to STATE LAW?  I request a meeting with our President and the Legal Committee and further state that if they don't schedule it, that I want one of the resident speaker positions during the June Board Meeting.  I'm given an appointment.  The President, Legal Chair, and the Treasurer attend.  The Treasurer tells me he never sent the email!  I have the email.  The Legal Chair stands over my shoulder looking at the email that the Treasurer has sent to the office and directed (in writing) that the office staff person send to me.  He has copied the entire board, including our President.  The office staff person walks out of the building.  When all is said and done I believe the only reason they met with me is because they had given one of the speaker spots to the Treasurer's spouse to retaliate against "a publication" in an open June Board Meeting.
*At this point in 2013, the board has made a number of changes to the Policy Manual, without following a by-law passed by the resident in 2011.  In the end it is discovered that our Legal Chair (then, and in 2013) hasn't taken the proper steps to have it registered legally in over 1 1/2 years!   Additionally, it hasn't even been added to the By-Laws  provided to residents on the WPA website.  Note:  The Treasurer/Drainage/ ARC member/COMPLIANCE Chair, has sat back month after month.
*SUSPICIOUS DRAINAGE BID AND CONTRACT AWARD:  The Drainage Chair asks the board to approve a contractor who bid $20 less than our grounds maintenance contractor, Great Lawns, to do drainage work.  I review the files. There is no request for proposal package.  Review of bids shows bidder figures crossed out and lower ones written in, reducing the bid to less than $20 than the Great Lawns bid. Your board approves the other contractor!!!
*Your board approves a grounds maintenance contract that leaves us supplementing the cost of private lot mowing and includes the spoil site.  This approval after months of cat and mouse games telling the Grounds' Chair they wouldn't have this or that.  One board member refers to this as looking "like KICK BACKS TO SOME PRIVATE LOT OWNERS".
*The Water Amenities Chair reports that they have SOLD THE OLD DOCK.   When asked by a board member what they received for the dock, neither the Water Amenities Chair, nor the Treasurer, will answer the question at the board table!  At this point, having transcribed the minutes for months, no one ever approved that they sell it, and your board snakes and no one asks who voted to give them permission to sell WPA property that was to be dissembled and hauled away.  The Water Amenities' Chair announces that he is removing the questioning board member from the Water Amenities Committee and your board officers, Legal Chair, and Compliance sits back and watches.
July
*The old dock still sits in the canals.  Your Water Amenities Chair fails to mention it in his report.  At the July meeting we observe this board playing the Wedgefield version of the Key Stone Cops.  "Get it out, it was never suppose to be there, it better not cost us", yet they never laid down the law in all these months, and now the contractor won't pull it out of the canals, and the buyer doesn't seem to be able to get it out of the canals. Your Legal Chair, when asked about liability if the dock harms private resident property, says it is on their private insurance - not the associations.
*It is announced that the Reserve Study is in the hands of the board.  The Treasurer wants to move $50,000 to reserves.  When asked if he'll use the reserve study allocations, he answers that he'll  use the allocation formula he has been using (HIS).  Our individual board members expertise trumps the study we all paid for.  The Wedgefield Examiner reviews the Reserve Study. It is tainted with notes by the contractor similar to "according to the board".  More of our individual board member expertise in the world according to them, and they won't use the study's figures??????  P.S.:  They wouldn't allow one of the board members speak to the vendor.  One begs to ask, "according to who, and which board members"? 
August
The Roads' Chair seeks approval to contract with engineering services for projected road projects.  Your board approves.  Yet, they don't want engineering services for drainage?????
*The Grounds' Chair discusses the possibility of  building a WPA maintenance shed to house maintenance equipment.  Don't we contract for maintenance services?????????????
*The old dock has been removed, but no one including the Water Amenities' Chair reports how or when.  No one on the board brings it up.  There was a sign at the place in the canals where the dock had resided for months that said, "ask the Wedgefield Examiner where the dock went."
September
*The Drainage Chair continues with the drainage contracts in his own neighborhood.  This time there is only one bid brought to the table.  A board member questions one bidder and the fact that  the projected projects for the Roads' Committee now have engineering support contracts, while drainage projects don't.  The questing board member is treated rudely and advised that it is felt that our Treasurer/Drainage/Compliance Chair along with our President, have the expertise that is good enough???????????
*Two board members question the projected 2014 operating budget and flow of funds from operating to reserves.  One of these board members calls what is happening "A SHELL GAME".
*The Legal Chair reports on the process of seeking legal action to collect on the $5,000 canal assessments. Your President doesn't seem to find it ironic and somewhat questionable that he has named this individual as Legal Chair.  Your board doesn't ever bring it up.  Yet, this gentleman is one of three "Bob's" who wrote residents telling them not to pay these assessments to the association, but to put them in an escrow account at Anderson Brothers Bank - impact the board's ability to pay the loan and conduct other business.  Additionally he has your board vote to add one of the other Bob's to the Legal Committee and your board approves.  Now these vary same men are advising the board and seeking legal advice on the vary people they told not to pay?????????
*This months ever changing finance report, constructed by our Treasurer's "in house accounting function group" (we don't know how much it is costing each month) has changed again, and it is one page with few details.
October
*Our Treasurer brings bids to the table to fix aspects of the gate house.  Low and behold the lowest bidder is our PRESIDENT.  A motion is brought to the table to contract with our PRESIDENT.  A board member says this is a conflict of interest and goes against our governing documents.  Our Legal Chair is rude, calls the questioning moronic.  Our PRESIDENT  says he'll withdraw his bid.  Our Treasurer/Drainage/Compliance Chair, who has managed this process and brought the motion to the table, refuses our PRESIDENT'S offer.  Your board members, minus the questioning board member, vote to contract with our PRESIDENT!  Not one of them - not our PRESIDENT, LEGAL CHAIR, or TREASURER/ DRAINAGE/COMPLIANCE CHAIR, or any of the Board except the one questioning, remember or acknowledge signing the CONFLICT OF INTEREST  statement!  Now, who is - let me use our Legal Chair's words, MORONIC?????
*During this month the Wedgefield  Examiner noted another attempt by this board to keep information from the residents.  I usually transcribe tapes from the Wedgefield Times.  The editor always has them posted within 24 - 48 hours of a meeting. He was unavailable, so I went to the WPA website and found, and then verified through the office, that they hadn't been posted for 8 MONTHS.
November
*Our annual meeting was held.  We had three board vacancies.  We had three candidates.  Two of them were running to fill their own soon, to be vacant board seats.  It appears that except for one, no one wanted to venture to work with this board.  Some residents actually wrote "no" next to their names.  The lowest number of residents in years voted.  Of course they won their seats back.  Two by-law amendments appeared on the ballot.  One was said to be submitted by the Legal Chair who is also Vice President.  If you attend meetings you know that our Legal Chair is not inclined to pay for written legal opinions.  As one board member states, they are left with hear say.  Our Legal Chair,  did seek a WRITTEN LEGAL OPINION for the amendments, provided by an attorney who came to be the Board Attorney of Record, under unusual circumstances.  If it was the Legal Chair's amendment, it appeared to violate our covenants, but it passed.

DECEMBER & COMMENTS & CONCLUSION OF THIS ARTICLE
The article ends with December.  After the November Annual Meeting one of the most critical actions of the board is to meet and elect their officers.  Once the officers are elected the President has the authority to name committee chairs.  Your board re-elected the same 2013 officers.  Your President, with minor exception named the same committee chairs, as he named in 2013.   I started the article on the premise that our immediate past performance is a strong indicator of our new immediate performance.  Who could be proud of the events listed above?    There wasn't room to detail  the horrible, distasteful behavior to any board member, usually one, who stood alone, and questioned and fought to uphold standards, governing documents, common strong business sense, etc., and was publicly abused and treated unethically, despite the fact that your President had everyone of them sign a Code of Ethics.  He didn't follow it, and neither did  more than a few others.  For those board members who didn't speak and abuse, they abused by sitting back, and voting in behalf of the ridiculous items noted above and watch the bullying.  You may have abused by not attending meetings, not writing, and demanding explanation or action.  You inadvertently condoned this and lessened the field of anyone considering running for this board.

I hold our President, our Officers, and those of you who just want to live and enjoy life responsible.  It might not be that wonderful.  Some of this board's nasty behavior could come knocking at your door soon.

In my not so humble opinion, our future for 2014 - our state of the union, looks dim.  We have left this board with unbridled trust to move forward, as they did in 2013.  Who could be proud of this governance over the place where we live, raise or welcome families, leave to go to work, school, or to retire and enjoy life?  The state of this union sickens me.  I'm tempted to send this off to surrounding HOAs and title it, "What Not To Allow To Happen In Your HOA"

PLEASE NOTE THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE WAS PULLED FROM TRANSCRIPTIONS OF MEETINGS AND REVIEW OF DUCMENTS.  I'VE DOCUMENTED THIS ARTICLE TO THE BEST OF MY ABILITY.