Total Pageviews

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

HAPPY HOLIDAYS ! THE WEDGEFIELD EXAMINER WILL BE ON HOLIDAY BREAK UNTIL JANUARY 4TH

A QUICK REVIEW OF THE DECEMBER 17 WPA BOARD MEETING AND POSSIBLY ANOTHER MYSTERIOUS SECTION ADDED TO THE POLICY MANUAL

The member attendance for this meeting equaled the number serving and present on the board - 9!  Thanks were given to the election committee and the people who decorated for the holidays. Minutes from the October regular board meeting were approved and the minutes to two "open meetings" called by the board.  A reserve account will be opened at a new bank (more to follow).

Overall the meeting moved quickly and without the usual drama. 

What was interesting was that as almost every committee chair gave their report they also sought approval for committee members for 2014.  We'll analyze the members approved for each committee later on.  De Marchi gave a Compliance Committee report for the first time in months.  He sought to change language under petty cash.  He did not name, or list, committee membership as many of the others did.  What is the treasurer of the organization - finance chair, member of several committees, doing serving as Compliance Chair?  Look at the conflict alone of the treasurer - finance chair, bringing a proposed change to the policy manual to the board for a vote.

A quick review of the current policy manual and those from 2002 and 2006 brought more questions than answers.  Shouldn't the list provided by the board on the website that lists the approved changes to the manual include the fact that Audit Committee was removed and a brand new one added - Compliance? Will Compliance end up having the same strange undocumented  appearance that the Confidentiality Agreement had?  We'll see as we look into it after the new year.

More to follow on the December meeting after the new year.

Sunday, December 15, 2013

IN WEDGEFIELD HOPE DOESN'T SPRING ETERNALLY - MEET YOUR 2014 OFFICERS AND COMMITTEE CHAIRS - SAME OLD, SAME OLD - IT MAY BE A LANDMARK YEAR - MAYBE WE'LL HAVE RISEN TO THE HEIGHT OF TOTAL DYSFUNCTION

You know the old saying hope springs eternal?  At the advent of a new year you'll often hear that phrase.  With the annual meeting comes a reorganization meeting.  The board elects new officers.  The president of the new board has the privilege of naming committee chairs.  Hope for change, even in the circumstance where we only really got one new board member, went out the door when you review the new officers - nothing changed, and committee chairs - minor cosmetic change in two areas.

PRESIDENT:  Walton, VICE PRESIDENT: Garrison, TREASURER:  De Marchi, SECRETARY:  Cline.  Nothing changed.  Once again your board elected Walton president.  Walton, as president, has the power to name the committee chairs.  Little changed in the committee chairs.  New board member, Keith Johnson was named ARC chair.  Adam Anderson was named Community Liaison.  Johnson has served on ARC for some time.  Anderson replaces Barrier as Community Liaison.  It shouldn't be a big job because your board hasn't answered residents in well over a year and infrequently before that.  When we had a management company whose responsibility was to answer residents, certain board members strangled the process to the point that no one got answered.

The point is that this board let Walton return to a job he has failed to handle.  His record speaks for itself.  As president, he should provide oversight to his board and their committee responsibilities.  The president should distance himself from sitting on individual committees, receive information and recommendations from them, and work with the chairs through scheduling  their reports on the agenda, noting motions to come to the table for a board vote, etc.  In his role of board and committee supervisor, if he stays out of committee membership, he observes with clean hands.  Instead, Walton has placed our governance in a incestuous position and exhibited total disregard of the benefits of true committee structure.

Incestuous?  Yes.  Your board doesn't publish the names of the individuals serving on committees.  I'm going to have to rely on memory.  If there is an error, please let me know and I'll will print a correction.  For the most part, your board stacks the committees with board members, rather than building committees in the true spirit of committees, that is the inclusion of new faces, ideas, etc.  Yes, our committees are incestuous, and built to keep out more people and their ideas, monitoring and contributing to our governance.  Take a look at the committees.  They are loaded with board members and our president's participation, rather than supervision.

ARC:  Walton, De Marchi, Johnson
LEGAL:  Garrison, Walton, De Marchi, (one resident)
FINANCE:  De Marchi, (3 residents)
ROADS:  Anderson (unsure whether any others are on the committee)
DRAINAGE: De Marchi, Walton, (unsure if others are on the committee)
WATER AMENITIES: Mc Millin, Anderson, Walton (John), Johnson, (some residents)  Should be noted that McBride had served on this committee but was thrown off the committee when he brought the dock in the canal issue to the board table. 
GROUNDS:  Mc Millin (No one else, I called the office about this committee a few months ago.)
WELCOME:  McBride (Has resident participation.)
COMPLIANCE:  De Marchi  (Uncertain if he has anyone left on this committee.  No reports in months.)  Note the committees De Marchi sits on and the fact that he is the treasurer and this is just a big NO, NO!
COMMUNICATION:  Cline

This committee set up, failure to list committee members, failure to post committee meeting reports, etc., just leads to secret deals, and poor governance, while taking away the power and benefits that real committee structure provides.

President Walton fails to oversee because he is in the middle of it all, rather than supervising it.  He has allowed chairs to remain in place who fail, not only to serve, but fail to perform at all - COMMUNITY LIAISON.  He sits by, or participates in the ugliness that takes place at the board table almost monthly, and speaks often in behalf of motions, that at times violate our governing documents.

Hope doesn't spring eternal for 2014 in Wedgefield.

 

THE WEDGEFIELD EXAMINER CELEBRATES 30,000 VISITS TO THE BLOG IN 25 MONTHS!



Friday, December 6, 2013

MORE QUESTIONS ARISE REGARDING CONFLICT OF INTEREST, CONTRACTING & PROCUREMENT, INTEGRITY, AND CODE OF ETHICS

If you haven't read the article immediately following this one, please read it before you proceed.  I'm sick of this board's lack of ability to conduct business in an open, ethical manner.  I'm sick of them not answering residents through legitimate correspondence, playing god (small "g" on purpose because it is an insult to the  standard), and arrogantly handling business in a dictator style, and treating members as though they aren't smart enough to see what the board doing.  If you've read the previous article you'll note for yourself that your entire board - minus one, ignored the "Conflict of Interest", that each and everyone of them signed.  The second document - our own WPA document, that they have failed for forever to follow, even though they all signed it, is the Code of Ethics.  This was supposedly so important that they had a signing of the Code of Ethics, AT THE BOARD TABLE.  I'm surprised they didn't each receive a signing pen like the president of the US does.  Every time they have been reasonably questioned by a board member on issues such as conflict of interest, they have abused the questioning board member - read the transcripts and listen to the tapes.  At one point Garrison called the questioning on conflict of interest moronic.  It is MORONIC that anyone would accept anything that comes out of their mouths, when they fail to live up to documents that they signed!

De Marchi's email to me calling for a retraction did nothing but send the mind to wondering why he protests too much.  If anything, it has caused further questions to arise out of the whole conflict of interest, regarding President Walton bidding and your board awarding him the contract to fix some aspects of the gate house.  The reasonable question, now moves to the bidding and contracting itself.  It is a question, not a statement of fact.  The blog is the only vehicle left.  Your board won't answer questions, make it difficult to review records - if they will allow it, and the questioner is demonized for asking.  Here's the question:  Was there conflict of interest in the bidding process for the gate house contract itself - even before the award?  You'll have to decide.  If it generates the question in your mind maybe you'll write and ask.  If you don't question and document, then you put wind beneath the wings of their poor, convoluted governance.

Think about the lead up to the contract award.  It appears your board doesn't have an approved bidding list.  A list of qualified vendors who they have checked credentials, insurance, previous performance, etc.  That would be good business.  We are told that the bid package was sent to three vendors.  I won't name the company that De Marchi noted in his email.  Read it for yourself.  We'll call it company "B".  De Marchi tells us that he had worked for company "B".  To my knowledge, company "B" hasn't bid on projects before.  When all is said and done (read the numbers), Walton's bid is very low, and company "B", is very high.  Since there was no approved bidding list to send requests for proposal to, was this a staged set up to give Walton the award?  Just asking?  Was the pricing staged?  It could easily appear to be that.  Just asking - not accusing anyone.  It looks bad.  So, your board has ignored strong standard procurement, two of the very documents they approved at the board table - Conflict of Interest and Code of Ethics, the advise of the experts that prepared the Reserve Study and constantly advise them to get outside vendors to handle the contract process and oversight and to seek engineering services, and awarded a contract to our president.

This whole thing, as so many others, looks tainted, shabby, and unethical.  Who is responsible?  Everyone on that board, minus one.  In regard to contracting, if they ever answered anyone, they'd sing their favorite song, "no one wants to work in Wedgefield".  Several years ago, a board sang a similar song and we paid one vendor over $700,000, built an office without a public -  at the board table vote, and paid a "builder", who had to use someone else's license.  As we approached a new election, Mc Millin verbally made contracting part of his platform.  When he was first elected, he proved over and over again that plenty of contractors were willing to work here - even on small $400 contracts.  Do we ever hear him go after this contracting mess now?  No.  You see, it could appear he gets what he wants when he cooperates and keeps his mouth shut like he did when your board approved one of his contracts that has all of us partially paying for individual lot mowing.  

Who amongst you will ask the questions and start to resolve this board regime and stop conflict of interest, intimidation at the board table, and bring ethics and strong governance, back to Wedgefield's board table?

P.S.  I finished this article and pushed the publish button and took a break.  Do you think the questions are "hard" on this cohesive board and some of the individual board members?  Think about this.  Much of this relates to contracting and contract awards and doing business openly and honestly.  Do the questions make you feel like there should be distrust of action and motive?  Possibly you don't attend the miserable monthly meetings, follow up with questions, and want the best for the place you call home.  In regard to contracting, I went to the office to review one of DeMarchi's first drainage projects in the Enclave.  There was NO written requests for bids with specs.  I reviewed the bids.  There were two.  One was a known contractor in good standing - Great Lawns.  Their bid was TWENTY DOLLARS more that the winning bid.  As I reviewed the second bid there were scratch outs on the typed bid with figures changed that brought the bid which was originally higher than Great Lawns, to $20 LESS.  Just one example.  You be the judge as to whether any thing looked SUSPICOUS to the average person.